The advent of an expanded five-man bench is reshaping AFL tactics, with coaches devising innovative strategies to leverage the increased interchange cap of 75. This season opener provided a fascinating glimpse into how clubs are adapting, from managing returning stars to integrating versatile role players and utilising fresh talent. The shift promises a more dynamic and unpredictable game, forcing high-performance staff to rethink player management and on-field execution.
Strategic Deployments: Managing Star Power and Injury Recovery
The early games have already showcased distinct approaches to utilising the extended bench. A prime example was the Sydney Swans’ management of Tom Papley in their season opener against Carlton. Swans coach Dean Cox explained that Papley, having endured an interrupted pre-season due to injury, was treated much like the original substitute player.
“We knew Tom had a limited pre-season in relation to matchplay,” Cox stated. “Like the old sub, if it was around, he would’ve been the sub or subbed out. We needed to make sure he got a certain amount of minutes. We need to build him. That was our plan. We needed to make sure we had Tom at the end of the game.”
Papley ultimately played 57 percent of the match. Despite limited game time, he proved instrumental in bursts, injecting much-needed energy and spark into the Swans’ forward line. This strategic approach allowed Papley to contribute significantly without being overexposed, a crucial consideration for a player returning from injury.
Carlton’s new recruit and ruckman, Liam Reidy, also experienced a measured introduction to the game. He spent nearly 40 percent of the match on the sidelines. His role was multifaceted, offering a forward target when needed and providing a breather for established ruckman Marc Pittonet during stoppages. This demonstrates how the extended bench allows for more specialised roles and tactical flexibility.
Integrating New Talent and Versatile Assets
The new interchange rules are also providing opportunities for debutants and developing players to make their mark. Brisbane’s debutant, Zane Zakostelsky, earned a senior call-up but was carefully managed, featuring for only 44 percent of the game. His contributions were primarily focused on centre ball-ups, showcasing his athleticism, with pinch-hitting in key forward positions when the situation demanded. This targeted deployment allows young players to experience senior football without being overwhelmed.
Geelong’s Jhye Clark was another player whose limited game time was used effectively. In their loss to Gold Coast, Clark was deployed sporadically across the field, with a 50 percent time-on-ground rate. He was injected into the midfield and also provided drive from half-back. Despite his limited minutes, Clark made a tangible impact, kicking one goal from 11 disposals and gaining 300 metres for his team. This highlights how even short, impactful stints can significantly influence a game.
The Masterclass: Scott Pendlebury’s ‘Sub’ Role Redefined
Perhaps the most compelling demonstration of the redefined “sub” role came from Collingwood’s strategic use of veteran Scott Pendlebury. The evergreen midfielder, who suffered a calf strain early in last season’s preliminary final loss to Brisbane, was afforded a more controlled playing load.
Pendlebury played 55 percent of the match. He was strategically held back in the first half and then deployed forward, where his renowned ability to slow the game down and create opportunities was on full display at the MCG.
His performance was nothing short of exceptional, culminating in a career-high five goal assists to go with his 26 touches. This epitomised the ideal “sub” in this new era: high impact, high reward, and strategically deployed to maximise his strengths and preserve his energy. Pendlebury’s experience and game sense, when applied in short, decisive bursts, proved invaluable.
As the rest of the competition prepares to implement their own strategies with the expanded five-man bench, the question remains: what other innovative tactics will coaches devise? The early signs suggest a more nuanced and exciting brand of football is on the horizon, driven by intelligent player management and the strategic deployment of every interchange opportunity. The extended bench is not just about more players; it’s about smarter football.
