War Crimes Allegations Against Ex-SAS Soldier Delayed by Classified Evidence
Sydney, Australia – Former Special Air Service (SAS) soldier Ben Roberts-Smith is facing significant delays in understanding the full scope of war crimes allegations levelled against him, with proceedings being pushed back by several months due to the inclusion of highly classified information. The 47-year-old, once Australia’s most decorated living soldier, was arrested in April and faces grave charges including the murder or ordering the murders of five unarmed detainees during his deployments in Afghanistan between 2009 and 2012.
The complexities surrounding national security have cast a shadow over the legal process, with the Downing Centre Local Court in Sydney being informed on Tuesday that the case is unlikely to progress significantly until September. Crown prosecutor Chelsea Brain explained to the court that Roberts-Smith cannot be provided with the complete brief of evidence detailing the accusations until specific court orders are in place to protect sensitive, classified information.

This crucial application concerning the top-secret material has been lodged by the federal government, underscoring the national security implications of the evidence. Roberts-Smith’s solicitor, Karen Espiner, indicated to the court that an agreement on the handling of these classified documents is likely to be reached between her client, the Crown prosecutors, and the government.
The responsibility now falls to Judge Susan Horan to be convinced of the necessity of these protective orders during a dedicated hearing scheduled for September. The National Security Information Act empowers judges to issue directives concerning the disclosure, storage, protection, handling, and even the eventual destruction of classified material within the context of criminal proceedings.
Roberts-Smith has yet to enter pleas to any of the charges. However, he has publicly stated his intention to use an upcoming trial to vigorously defend his reputation and clear his name. He was granted bail in April, with his father, Len Roberts-Smith – a former judge of the Western Australia Supreme Court – providing a $250,000 surety.

Grave Allegations Emerge
The allegations against Roberts-Smith are deeply disturbing and paint a grim picture of alleged atrocities committed during his service. Court documents, which have been reviewed by AAP, detail several specific incidents:
The Whiskey 108 Raid (April 2009): Roberts-Smith is accused of machine-gunning an Afghan prisoner named Mohammed Essa. Furthermore, he allegedly ordered the execution of Essa’s son, Ahmadullah, who reportedly had a prosthetic leg. This alleged act was purportedly carried out to “blood the rookie,” a chilling euphemism for initiating a new soldier into combat through a killing. Following these killings, it is alleged that firearms were placed on the bodies to falsely portray the deceased as enemy combatants.
The Darwan Village Incident (August 2012): In this alleged incident, Roberts-Smith is accused of kicking a handcuffed Ali Jan off a 10-metre cliff. Following this, court documents claim he ordered that Jan be dragged across a creek bed and subsequently shot.
The Syahchow Incident (October 2012): Two months later, at Syahchow, Roberts-Smith is alleged to have lined up two prisoners in a cornfield. One of these prisoners was reportedly shot by another soldier. Roberts-Smith then allegedly ordered a subordinate to shoot the second prisoner. To conceal these actions, it is claimed that a grenade was thrown onto the bodies.
These serious allegations have significant implications for Roberts-Smith’s military record and his public standing. The protracted legal process, exacerbated by the need to manage classified evidence, means that a clear understanding of the case’s full trajectory will remain uncertain for some time.
For individuals seeking support, the following helplines are available:
Lifeline: 13 11 14
Open Arms: 1800 011 046


