🔥 TERKINI

Tasmania Bans ‘Good Character’ Defence for Serious Crimes

Luna Oleh: Luna
7 dilihat
Kamis, 12 Maret 2026 - 06:26 WIB • Waktu baca: 4 menit
Iklan Atas Artikel (Before Content)

Tasmania Moves to Scrap “Good Character” References in Sentencing for Serious Offences

The Tasmanian government is taking a significant step towards overhauling sentencing practices, with a strong intention to eliminate the use of “good character” references in cases of serious offending. Attorney-General Guy Barnett announced the government’s determination to align sentencing with contemporary community standards, a move he believes will provide greater justice for victims.

“As a government, we are determined to ensure that sentencing meets modern community standards,” Mr Barnett stated. He emphasised the importance of this reform for victims, asserting that they should not be subjected to hearing about the “good character” of the person who has harmed them during court proceedings. Mr Barnett has been actively engaging with advocacy groups and survivors of crime, acknowledging their crucial role and ongoing support in driving this initiative.

Currently, “good character” evidence can serve as a mitigating factor for offenders during sentencing in Tasmania. However, legislation introduced in 2016 already placed restrictions on its use in sexual offence cases, preventing courts from considering an offender’s good character if it aided them in committing the crime. The proposed changes aim to extend this restriction to all serious offending, with a potential exception for lesser offences under specific circumstances.

Tasmanian MP Bridget Archer indicated that draft legislation is expected to be released in the first half of the current year, signalling a swift progression towards these reforms.

National Momentum Builds as Jurisdictions Rethink Character References

Tasmania’s proposed legislative amendments are part of a growing national trend. Several other Australian jurisdictions have already signalled or implemented similar changes, aiming to remove the influence of character references in mitigating sentences. This broader shift is being celebrated by advocates who see it as a crucial step in ensuring the justice system better reflects community expectations and prioritises the experiences of victims and survivors.

Harrison James, co-founder of the “Your Reference Ain’t Relevant” campaign and a survivor of child sexual abuse, described the current situation as one of “national momentum.” He expressed optimism about the ongoing constructive dialogue with governments and legal experts, aiming to ensure sentencing laws across Australia adequately acknowledge the impact of harm and uphold accountability.

Mr James’s advocacy for these changes began two years ago with a meeting with Mr Barnett, and he has maintained regular contact with the Attorney-General’s office. Alongside Jarad Grice, he launched their campaign in 2022, successfully advocating for legislative reforms in multiple states.

  • Australian Capital Territory (ACT): In December of last year, the ACT introduced new laws rendering character references irrelevant in sentencing for child sexual offences.
  • New South Wales (NSW): In February, NSW announced similar legislation to abolish the use of good character references for convicted offenders during sentencing.
  • Victoria: Victoria has also committed to removing good character references for convicted criminals.
  • Queensland: Last September, Queensland implemented legislative changes that limited the consideration of an offender’s “good character” as a mitigating factor. Under these new provisions, good character can only be considered if it is directly relevant to the offender’s prospects of rehabilitation or their likelihood of reoffending.

Restoring Confidence and Evolving Justice

The swift succession of legislative changes in recent months underscores a broader societal recognition that the practice of using character references to lessen sentences for serious crimes no longer aligns with modern community expectations.

“Victims and survivors don’t have to hear that their perpetrator or abuser is a ‘good bloke’ or a ‘pillar of the community’,” Mr James commented. He believes these reforms can help restore faith in the justice system for survivors, demonstrating a greater understanding of their experiences and a commitment to evolving the law to better address the realities of harm.

Mr James remains committed to extending these reforms to all remaining states and territories, and also to addressing federal crimes, as he notes that “these crimes, they don’t discriminate by state borders.”

Counterarguments and the Balancing Act of Sentencing

However, the proposed changes have also met with some reservations. Greg Barns SC, a spokesperson for the Australian Lawyers Alliance (ALA), suggested that these reforms could complicate sentencing proceedings.

“It’s unfair to defendants who come before the court who might have committed an offence in circumstances where they had a drug addiction, for example, or it was an alcohol-infused offence,” Mr Barns argued. He highlighted the importance of courts having a complete picture of an individual, including any positive attributes, when determining an appropriate sentence.

The ALA has stated it does not support an “extension to the current system which relates to sexual abuse,” emphasizing that sentencing should consider both the victim and the defendant. “It needs to be understood that the courtroom is not simply focused on the victim. It’s also focused on the defendant, as it should be, because the sentencing has to be appropriate,” Mr Barns concluded.

Tinggalkan Tanggapan

Indeks Berita →